Let the church be the church.

“Do not trust in princes, in a son of man, in whom there is no salvation.” – Psalm 146:3

Beware the Benevolent State

The greatest threat isn’t always tyranny wrapped in cruelty—

It’s tyranny wrapped in compassion.

History proves it: some of the most oppressive regimes—from Fascist states to Communist revolutions—began with good intentions.

They promised justice, equality, and the betterment of humanity.

But their utopian visions led to dystopian realities, marked by surveillance, coercion, mass suffering, and death.

When we empower the state to play the role of savior—to heal, provide, and morally shape society—we do not get paradise.

We get a godless substitute for the church and a godlike substitute for Christ.

“Do not trust in princes, in a son of man, in whom there is no salvation.” – Psalm 146:3

Let the church be the church.

Let the state be the state.

But never confuse Caesar for Christ.

Governments that promise mercy, equality, and justice—while asking for more power and more money to do it—don’t build utopias.

They build dystopias.

Benevolence without limits always becomes bondage.

The Danger of Concentrated Government Power

One of the greatest threats to liberty and human flourishing is the unchecked concentration of political power.

History bears this out again and again—whether it's fascism, communism, or other forms of totalitarianism, the pattern is the same:

More power + more money + more control = less freedom, less virtue, more tyranny.

When a government assumes roles never assigned to it by God, what begins as benevolence almost always ends in bondage.

Biblical Wisdom: Distinguishing Church and State

When the church shovels off its calling—to love, serve, disciple, and show mercy—into the hands of the government, we:

-- Relieve believers of personal responsibility, dulling the call to obedience and sacrifice.

-- Weaken the church’s witness, making it seem irrelevant in a watching world.

-- Empower a morally divided and often compromised institution to enforce a politicized version of compassion.

-- Pave the way for invasive control and spiritual atrophy, as the church grows passive and the state grows godlike.

-- Support morally objectionable causes with our taxes and political loyalty—things Scripture condemns.

-- Yoke the church with unbelievers, violating 2 Corinthians 6:14 and blurring the line between Christ and Caesar.

-- Trust in the arm of flesh, depending on human power to do what only the Spirit can accomplish through the body of Christ.

“Thus says the Lord: ‘Cursed is the man who trusts in man and makes flesh his strength, whose heart turns away from the Lord.’” – Jeremiah 17:5

The Bottom Line:

When we ask Caesar to do what only Christ and His church can do,

we don’t get salvation—we get substitution.

No matter how noble the cause or compassionate the language,

when the church asks the state to do its work, it doesn’t just compromise—it commits idolatry.

It trades Christ for Caesar.

That’s not righteousness. That’s betrayal.

Mercy is not merely an outward action—it requires a spiritual disposition, grounded in the gospel and empowered by the Holy Spirit.

Mercy without Christ is not true mercy—it’s humanitarianism, which may alleviate pain but cannot heal souls.

It splits mercy from its divine source, replacing the redemptive with the pragmatic, the personal with the political.

Biblical Warnings About Political Power

The Bible contains clear warnings against kings, tyrants, and the dangers of concentrated power in human rulers.

God permits civil authority (Romans 13), but Scripture repeatedly shows that trusting in man over God leads to oppression, idolatry, and judgment.

Here are just a few examples:

1 Samuel 8:10–18 – The warning against Israel’s desire for a king

Deuteronomy 17:14–20 – God’s law placing limits on kings

Psalm 146:3 – “Do not trust in princes...”

Isaiah 10:1–2 – Injustice written into law

Ecclesiastes 5:8 – Bureaucratic oppression

Daniel 4:28–37 – Nebuchadnezzar’s humiliation

Daniel 7:2–8 – Beastly empires

Habakkuk 1:13–17 – Tyranny and unchecked violence

Matthew 20:25–28 – “The rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them...”

John 18:36 – “My kingdom is not of this world.”

Acts 12:21–23 – Herod judged for self-deification

Revelation 13:1–10 – The beast from the sea (totalitarian state power)

Revelation 17:1–6 – Babylon the prostitute (corrupt political and spiritual power)

Revelation 18 – The fall of Babylon (God’s judgment on oppressive empire)

Article From Monergism

Image

Bible Study : The Church and the State